2009 Co-Champions
Alfred University ,
St. John Fisher College

2008 Champions
Ithaca College

2007 Co-Champions
Hartwick College,
St. John Fisher College

2006 Co-Champions
St. John Fisher College,
Springfield College

2005 Champions
Ithaca College

2004 Co-Champions
Ithaca College,
St. John Fisher College

2003 Champions
Ithaca College

2002 Champions
Ithaca College